Forum

Sonicwall NSA 240 -...
 
Bildirimler
Hepsini Temizle

Sonicwall NSA 240 - Fortigate 110C Karşılaştırması.

8 Yazılar
6 Üyeler
0 Likes
551 Görüntüleme
(@fcelik)
Gönderiler: 49
Trusted Member
Konu başlatıcı
 

Network altyapımızda değişikliğe gitmek istiyoruz. Yaklaşık 150 terminalimiz mevcut ve web, mail hizmetlerini dış firmadan alıyoruz. Satınalma öncesi karar sürecinde kullanan arkadaşların değerlendirmeleri iyi birer yönlendirici olacak.


 İç ağımızda ayrıca internet çıkışlarında şifre sorgulaması yapmak istiyoruz. FW üzerinde oluşturulacak kullanıcı hesapları ile yetkilendirme ve yönetim imkanı sağlamak amacındayız. Kullanıcı hesapları domainden bağımsız ayrı bir liste olarak tutulacak. Ayrıca kanun kapsamında tutulması gereken loglar tutulacak ve kanun kapsamında muhafazası sağlanacak. Sonicwall ın QNAP ile tümleşik logsign Fortigate inde Fortianalyzer cihazları mevcut. QNAP kapasite olarak avantaj sağlıyor, ayrıca sonicwall ın multicore işlemci teknolojisi biraz öne çıkıyor gibi. Konu ile ilgili görüş bildirecek arkadaşlara şimdiden teşekkür ederim.

 
Gönderildi : 20/11/2009 20:54

(@ozgurkolukisa)
Gönderiler: 53
Trusted Member
 

Merhaba,


Sonicwall kullanmadım bilmiyorum ama Fortigate bu istediklerinizi  yapabiliyor bildiğim kadarıyla. Ayrıca ISA yada F.Front TMG gibi soft alternatiflerde var. En azından hem donanım hemde yazılım açısından çok daha esneklerdir.


 


kolay gelsin.

 
Gönderildi : 20/11/2009 23:37

(@MehmetYALVAC)
Gönderiler: 14
Eminent Member
 

Bende aynı karar verme durumundayım. Acaba hangi marka üzerinde karar verdiğinizi sebepleri ile birlikte burda paylaşabilir misiniz? Şimdiden çok teşekkürler... 

 
Gönderildi : 22/11/2010 19:35

(@MehmetYALVAC)
Gönderiler: 14
Eminent Member
 

Bende aynı kararı verme durumundayım. Acaba hangi marka üzerinde karar verdiğinizi sebepleri ile birlikte burda paylaşabilir misiniz? Şimdiden çok teşekkürler... 

 
Gönderildi : 22/11/2010 19:35

(@ErhanSARISARAY)
Gönderiler: 16
Eminent Member
 

tamda aradığım konu arkadaşlar karşılaştırma yapabilirmisiniz.Bende karar veremedim bu iki ürün arasında

 
Gönderildi : 18/03/2011 14:20

(@TuncayBAS)
Gönderiler: 139
Estimable Member
 





 


 











































































































































































SonicWALL NSA 240 (01-SSC-8760) Firewall


Fortinet, Inc. FORTIGATE-110C W/ 1YR PREM COMP PROTECT BDL - FG-110C-BDL-US Firewall


Product Description


 


 


 


NSA 240 Network Security Appliance is a next-generation Unifi ed Threat Management (UTM) against a comprehensive array of attacks, combining intrusion prevention, anti-virus and antispyware... More


NSA 240 Network Security Appliance is a next-generation Unifi ed Threat Management (UTM) against a comprehensive array of attacks, combining intrusion prevention, anti-virus and antispyware with the application-level control of SonicWALL Application Firewall. with advanced routing, state-full high-availability and high-speed VPN technology. Less


The FortiGate-110C is a low/mid-range platform designed for small and medium enterprises, and remote or branch offices of larger enterprises. The FG-110C is specifically designed to answer... More


The FortiGate-110C is a low/mid-range platform designed for small and medium enterprises, and remote or branch offices of larger enterprises. The FG-110C is specifically designed to answer the security challenges faced by SMB/ROBO customers with limited network administrator staff and lean budgets who simultaneously face legislative mandates and future network expansion concerns. In response to these needs, the FG-110C is designed to provide the best performance and highest port count on the market, all in a single device that installs in minutes and updates itself automatically. Less


Product MPN


 


 


MPN


01-SSC-8760


FG-110C-BDL-US


Key Features


 


 


Connectivity  


Wired


Unknown


Firewall Features


Stateful Packet Inspection (SPI) • DoS Prevention • Intrusion Prevention • NAT • Antivirus Filtering • Antispam Filtering


Stateful Packet Inspection (SPI) • DoS Prevention • Intrusion Prevention • NAT • Antivirus Filtering • Antispam Filtering


NAT Support  


Static • Dynamic • NAT Traversal


Static • Dynamic • NAT Traversal


Performance


 


 


Clear Text Throughput


600 Mbps


500 Mbps


VPN Throughput


150 Mbps


100 Mbps


Concurrent Connections


2000


10000


Installed RAM


256 MB


256 MB


Ports


 


 


LAN Ports


9


8


Configurable Ports


9


10


Protocols


 


 


Transport Protocol


HTTP • ICMP/IP • IPSec • L2TP • PPPoE • PPTP • TCP/IP • UDP/IP • VoIP • HTTPS


HTTP • ICMP/IP • IPSec • L2TP • PPPoE • PPTP • TCP/IP • UDP/IP • VoIP • HTTPS


WLAN Standards


IEEE 802.11a • IEEE 802.11b • IEEE 802.11g • IEEE 802.1 Q


Unknown


Routing Protocols


OSPF • RIP Version 1 • RIP Version 2 • Static Routing


OSPF • RIP Version 1 • RIP Version 2 • Static Routing


DHCP Support  


Client • Server


Client • Server


Remote Management Protocol  


HTTP • SNMP 2 • SSH • HTTPS


HTTP • SNMP 2 • SSH • HTTPS•TELNET


VPN


 


 


Authentication


RADIUS • LDAP • Active Directory • Secure Shell (SSH) • X.509 • SHA-1 • MD5


RADIUS • LDAP • Active Directory • Secure Shell (SSH) • X.509 • SHA-1 • MD5


Encryption Standards  


DES • 3DES • MD5 • IKE • SHA-1 • PKI


DES • 3DES • MD5 • IKE • SHA-1 • PKI


VPN Tunnels


25


1500


Included Licenses


2 Users


No users


Dimensions


 


 


Width


10.5 in.


13 in.


Depth


7.1 in.


10 in.


Height


1.5 in.


1.8 in.


Weight


2.6 lb.


6 lb.


Warranty


 


 


Warranty


1 Year


Unknown


Miscellaneous


 


 


UPC


758479087601


94922841360


Product ID


74961907


75362929


 

 
Gönderildi : 18/03/2011 15:10

(@TuncayBAS)
Gönderiler: 139
Estimable Member
 





 


 











































































































































































SonicWALL NSA 240 (01-SSC-8760) Firewall


Fortinet, Inc. FORTIGATE-110C W/ 1YR PREM COMP PROTECT BDL - FG-110C-BDL-US Firewall


Product Description


 


 


 


NSA 240 Network Security Appliance is a next-generation Unifi ed Threat Management (UTM) against a comprehensive array of attacks, combining intrusion prevention, anti-virus and antispyware... More


NSA 240 Network Security Appliance is a next-generation Unifi ed Threat Management (UTM) against a comprehensive array of attacks, combining intrusion prevention, anti-virus and antispyware with the application-level control of SonicWALL Application Firewall. with advanced routing, state-full high-availability and high-speed VPN technology. Less


The FortiGate-110C is a low/mid-range platform designed for small and medium enterprises, and remote or branch offices of larger enterprises. The FG-110C is specifically designed to answer... More


The FortiGate-110C is a low/mid-range platform designed for small and medium enterprises, and remote or branch offices of larger enterprises. The FG-110C is specifically designed to answer the security challenges faced by SMB/ROBO customers with limited network administrator staff and lean budgets who simultaneously face legislative mandates and future network expansion concerns. In response to these needs, the FG-110C is designed to provide the best performance and highest port count on the market, all in a single device that installs in minutes and updates itself automatically. Less


Product MPN


 


 


MPN


01-SSC-8760


FG-110C-BDL-US


Key Features


 


 


Connectivity  


Wired


Unknown


Firewall Features


Stateful Packet Inspection (SPI) • DoS Prevention • Intrusion Prevention • NAT • Antivirus Filtering • Antispam Filtering


Stateful Packet Inspection (SPI) • DoS Prevention • Intrusion Prevention • NAT • Antivirus Filtering • Antispam Filtering


NAT Support  


Static • Dynamic • NAT Traversal


Static • Dynamic • NAT Traversal


Performance


 


 


Clear Text Throughput


600 Mbps


500 Mbps


VPN Throughput


150 Mbps


100 Mbps


Concurrent Connections


2000


10000


Installed RAM


256 MB


256 MB


Ports


 


 


LAN Ports


9


8


Configurable Ports


9


10


Protocols


 


 


Transport Protocol


HTTP • ICMP/IP • IPSec • L2TP • PPPoE • PPTP • TCP/IP • UDP/IP • VoIP • HTTPS


HTTP • ICMP/IP • IPSec • L2TP • PPPoE • PPTP • TCP/IP • UDP/IP • VoIP • HTTPS


WLAN Standards


IEEE 802.11a • IEEE 802.11b • IEEE 802.11g • IEEE 802.1 Q


Unknown


Routing Protocols


OSPF • RIP Version 1 • RIP Version 2 • Static Routing


OSPF • RIP Version 1 • RIP Version 2 • Static Routing


DHCP Support  


Client • Server


Client • Server


Remote Management Protocol  


HTTP • SNMP 2 • SSH • HTTPS


HTTP • SNMP 2 • SSH • HTTPS•TELNET


VPN


 


 


Authentication


RADIUS • LDAP • Active Directory • Secure Shell (SSH) • X.509 • SHA-1 • MD5


RADIUS • LDAP • Active Directory • Secure Shell (SSH) • X.509 • SHA-1 • MD5


Encryption Standards  


DES • 3DES • MD5 • IKE • SHA-1 • PKI


DES • 3DES • MD5 • IKE • SHA-1 • PKI


VPN Tunnels


25


1500


Included Licenses


2 Users


No users


Dimensions


 


 


Width


10.5 in.


13 in.


Depth


7.1 in.


10 in.


Height


1.5 in.


1.8 in.


Weight


2.6 lb.


6 lb.


Warranty


 


 


Warranty


1 Year


Unknown


Miscellaneous


 


 


UPC


758479087601


94922841360


Product ID


74961907


75362929


 

 
Gönderildi : 18/03/2011 15:11

(@Cenk-Celik)
Gönderiler: 100
Estimable Member
 

Zyxel Zywall usg 300 yada üzeri modellerinden biri..........

 
Gönderildi : 19/03/2011 17:21

Paylaş: